🔗 Share this article

Typically, the NFL's Head Coach of the Year trophy adheres to a simple script. It often functions as a form of apology. We regret we got wrong your squad in our pre-campaign projections.

Theoretically, it's a direct path: the coach who orchestrated the largest turnaround wins the prize. In reality, it fuels an annual debate about preseason outlooks and whether we're genuinely honoring superior coaching or merely the greatest shock.

Yet the latest race is fundamentally different. The pool of contenders is remarkably deep. It has been the year of comebacks. The league has been messy, with reigning conference winners fading and longtime also-rans rising collectively. In an ordinary season, Sean Payton leading the his team to the summit of the conference would make him the overwhelming front-runner. But in such a turbulent and entertaining year, he's up against multiple other elite coaches.

Below is how the hypothetical vote ought to be structured.

5) Ben Johnson, His Team, Their Record

Voters for Coach of the Year voters are fascinated by QBs. This is a tradition. A certain coach in 2017. Kevin Stefanski in 2020. A third in 2022. When you fix a quarterback, you're well on your way to winning the award.

Ben Johnson hasn't just corrected Caleb Williams; he's unlocked him. In the right system, the QB has been given the chance to demonstrate his special ability. Since midseason onward, the Bears sit at fourth in offensive Expected Points Added per play. That's not a lucky run – it's sustained dominance. With Johnson, the quarterback has become more decisive, less careless, and has eagerly surrendered to the gameplan rather than freelancing. It is an offense built entirely in the coach's image: a physical ground attack, a steady dose of play-action passes and a imaginative passing attack that frees wide-open targets consistently. Williams has capitalized. And when openings weren't available, he's been capable to spin big plays out of nothing.

The coach came to the Bears with a clear offensive philosophy. Virtually each gamble – rebuilding the offensive line, highlighting the pass-catchers, turning the QB into a rhythm passer – has worked. That's rare for a rookie head coach. And it's even more uncommon yet for a leader who walked into the organization with the kind of pressure he did. For two straight cycles, he was the hottest name on the coaching market. But when it comes to hiring a head coach, there are zero guarantees. Remarkably, Johnson has lived up to the hype – and even exceeded them. He's proven not just to be a offensive wizard but the kind of culture builder that can inject fresh energy into an franchise.

During a normal season, Johnson would be the clear-cut choice. Yet this isn't a normal season!

Where Johnson's candidacy comes a bit into trouble is on the defensive side. The Bears presently rank in the bottom third in defensive success rate. They are surviving on turnovers, and takeaways are notoriously inconsistent. Coaches can focus on ball disruption, but no one can ensure it. He is on the ballot because the offensive production is sustainable. He's ranked lower because luck is doing too much of the defensive work. If not for a few breaks of the ball, the team would be two wins behind. It's been an exceptional turnaround, and the foundation is in place for long-term success. However Johnson falls just short in this ranking.

4) The Jacksonville Jaguars Coach, His Team, Their Record

Coen is in a comparable situation to Johnson. He's another first-time leader who has engineered a rapid turnaround. During the stretch run of the season, he has Trevor Lawrence playing the finest all-around ball of his career. And he's also spearheaded the transformation of a defense that now sits at number five in the league in EPA per play.

Even more impressively, he has nailed the intangibles stuff, which wasn't a guarantee after his early public introduction and some of his preseason moves.

The coach took over Jacksonville with an exceptionally raw coaching staff. Unlike Johnson, who surrounded their staff with the ideal coaching blend of new ideas and experience, he hired first-timers. From the leader on down to coordinators to assistant coaches, the Jags are stocked with first-timers. That type of setup is exciting on paper, but frequently collapses in reality – as past failures are a cautionary tale – because everybody is figuring out a new job in real-time. Yet he has managed to bring everyone and all elements into sync.

After an initial strong beginning, there was a chance that the season would veer off the track. A midseason collapse caused the team stumbling once more. That's usually when leaders panic and change too much. He did not. Instead, he streamlined things. The offense stopped chasing home-run answers and started hunting reliable ones. The coach recentered the offense around key players and the running game, and encouraged his QB to use his legs more often.

The outcomes are evident. The Jaguars have won seven games consecutively and will be the AFC's number three seed. He receives the slightest deduction in the standings because he inherited a talented team, but he has proven he can get the most out of that talent.

3) Mike Macdonald, Seattle Seahawks, 13-3

Every Coach of the Year argument has a hinge decision. For Mike Macdonald, it was his QB move.

Moving on from a incumbent, bringing in a different quarterback and pairing him with an innovative play-caller could have derailed the season in the early weeks. Rather, it shaped it. Through the mid point of the season, the new QB was an MVP candidate. He has regressed since that time, dropping to a lower rank in efficiency per dropback over the second half of the season, putting him just one spot ahead of peers.

Still